Six weeks later, Alan hated it.
Not the software. Alan remained almost evangelically enthusiastic about the software. He had been using the latest build to interrogate his own plumbing business with the zeal of a newly appointed detective investigating himself. He had discovered that he undercharged for emergency call-outs, drove forty-three unnecessary miles in an average week, had seven customers approaching predictable boiler failures and made substantially more money from bathrooms than he had previously suspected, owing largely to his habit of thinking about money only when he didn't have enough of it.
It was the mailer Alan hated.
“This is fucking creepy, Darren.”
Darren folded his arms.
Alan had just read the ninth generated email. The first eight had produced an interesting deterioration in his mood: amusement, admiration, puzzlement, silence, suspicion and finally the expression of a man who had discovered that his new doorbell could identify his childhood fears.
The ninth was addressed to Mrs Campbell.
It asked how she was keeping, mentioned—without making a production of it—that spring was coming and she would presumably soon be disappearing into the garden again, then segued with almost indecent naturalness into the fact that her boiler was due a service. It sounded like Alan. Not approximately like Alan, either. It had his preference for Hi over Hello, his short paragraphs, his aversion to exclamation marks, his tendency to put anyway at the beginning of sentences where it performed no grammatical function whatever. It even knew not to mention Mrs Campbell's late husband while nevertheless adjusting the emotional temperature of the message around his absence.
Alan read it again.
“How does it know about the garden?”
“Facebook.”
“I didn't know about the garden.”
“Facebook did.”
“I'm not friends with her on Facebook.”
“You don't have to be. Her gardening posts are public.”
Alan looked at Darren.
“It's public information, Alan. She published it.”
“She published it for people who like gardens.”
“She published it on the internet.”
“That's not the same thing.”
“It is technically very close to the same thing.”
Alan pushed his chair backwards.
“Show me another.”
Darren selected Mike, the garage owner.
The resulting email was shorter, mildly abusive and ended by suggesting that Mike book his boiler service before it “finally shits itself in January and you ring Alan pretending nobody could possibly have predicted this.”
Alan laughed despite himself.
“That is fucking good.”
“Exactly.”
“No. Don't exactly me. That's what's bothering me. It's too fucking good.”
Darren stared at him.
The objection seemed malformed.
Alan read three more. One was warm. One brisk. One almost formally polite. None resembled the others except in purpose. The system had ceased to produce mailshots in any meaningful sense. It produced temporary simulations of Alan addressing temporary simulations of individual customers, each assembled for the occasion from whatever the machine knew, inferred, suspected or had quietly picked up while nobody was looking.
“You told me these people were individuals,” Darren said.
“They are.”
“So I made the system treat them as individuals.”
Darren waited.
“This is...like, stalking people online.”
“Oh, for fuck's sake.”
“It knows Mrs Campbell likes gardening and I don't.”
“Which rather demonstrates its usefulness.”
“It scares the shit out of me.”
Darren walked to the window.
This was profoundly disappointing. Not because Alan had found a technical deficiency; Darren would have welcomed one. Technical deficiencies possessed the great moral advantage of being soluble. Alan was rejecting the feature precisely because it worked.
“I've spent six weeks on this.”
“I know.”
“I've personally checked hundreds of outputs. Not automated tests. Me. I've sat here reading the fucking things. The final pass compares every message against the customer model, the relationship model and your own language model. It rejects anything with low confidence. It suppresses sensitive information. It checks whether a fact is appropriate to use, not merely whether it's true.”
“I don't want it knowing the fact in the first place.”
“That makes no sense.”
“It makes complete sense to me.”
“I've basically built Palantir for plumbers and you want an edit button.”
Alan laughed once, helplessly.
“That's not the selling point you think it is.”
Alan didn't know about the health inferences, the third-party datasets or the two APIs whose documentation had been conspicuously incurious about where several billion rows of consumer information had originated. This was probably not the moment to broaden his education. Darren had constructed the system responsibly. Health data carried a low relevance weighting unless independently corroborated; medication-derived inference was lower still; nothing medically sensitive could appear explicitly in an outgoing message, and an additional AI pass existed specifically to prevent the sort of lunacy in which a boiler-service reminder accidentally revealed that the boiler-service reminder knew you were taking Citalopram.
Thank fuck he hadn't demonstrated the health-confidence field.
Alan stood.
“Look, mate, I'm still using the software. I love the software. But this bit? No. And I'm telling you now, most trades guys I know won't touch it either.”
“They'll touch it when they see the response rates.”
Alan picked up his jacket.
“Put the edit button in. Let the system draft something from the information I've actually given it, then let me change it. That's all I wanted.”
“That is mediocre.”
“It's plumbing.”
“That's irrelevant.”
“Not to the plumber.”
After Alan had gone, Darren remained by the window for several minutes, furious principally because Alan had identified the problem correctly six weeks earlier and was now refusing to accept its solution.
People were individuals.
Fine.
Darren had built individuality into the architecture.
Not crude demographic segments. Not WOMEN 45–60, HOMEOWNER, SOUTH-EAST, the sort of informational vandalism marketing departments had been committing against humanity since somebody first discovered the pie chart. Actual people. Three hundred customers meant three hundred evolving models. History, temperament, language, circumstances, preferences, confidence scores, decay rates, exceptions. The system could write a hundred emails in seconds and each would have been written differently because each recipient was different.
And Alan wanted an edit box.
There were moments when Darren suspected the principal obstacle to technological progress was the people it was intended to benefit.
He pushed all of that to the back of his mind.
He needed to run an errand.
The keyboard he had punished through six weeks of development had also begun intermittently declining to acknowledge the letter E, which made programming inconvenient and English vindictive, so he drove first to an electronics shop in the retail park.
He hadn't been there for perhaps two years.
Something was wrong immediately.
Not dramatically wrong. Worse: aesthetically wrong.
The shop had acquired the smooth, sparse confidence of an airport lounge designed by people frightened of luggage. Great illuminated signs hung above the departments.
COMPUTERS
SCREENS
PHONES
SOUND
Darren walked towards the keyboards.
There were three.
He stopped.
The boxes were white.
KEYBOARD
KEYBOARD PLUS
KEYBOARD PRO
He picked up the Pro.
“Pro what?” he said.
The box offered no answer.
Wireless. Rechargeable. Comfortable keys. Works with most computers.
He turned it over.
That was essentially the specification.
No switch type. No actuation force. No rollover specification. No polling information. Nothing about key travel. Nothing that might permit one keyboard to be distinguished from another by a person whose requirements extended beyond possession of fingers.
An assistant appeared.
“Need any help?”
“Yes. Where are your mechanical keyboards?”
The assistant looked at the display.
“These are the keyboards.”
“I can see that.”
A pause.
“I mean the mechanical ones.”
“They've all got keys.”
Darren looked at him.
The young man wasn't being facetious.
“What switches does this use?”
“Switches?”
“Under the keys.”
The assistant turned the box over, thereby independently discovering the same absence Darren had already discovered.
“It doesn't say.”
“No.”
“Probably standard.”
“Standard what?”
Another pause.
“I can check.”
“Please.”
The assistant disappeared.
Darren moved on.
Mice.
MOUSE
MOUSE PLUS
MOUSE PRO
He laughed.
Screens.
Not monitors. Apparently monitor had itself become prohibitively specialised.
SCREEN 24
SCREEN 27
SCREEN 32
He picked up the 27.
Resolution: High Definition.
Which fucking definition?
Refresh rate: Smooth.
Darren stared at the word.
“Smooth.”
He checked another.
Brightness: Bright.
The assistant had not returned.
Darren walked through SOUND, where headphones were available in GOOD, PLUS and PRO, although what professional activity the latter had been credentialled to perform was unclear. A speaker advertised itself as LOUD. A webcam promised CLEAR VIDEO. A printer printed FAST.
He took out his phone.
The shop's website was no better.
Products had photographs, prices, star ratings and little green buttons inviting purchase. Technical specifications appeared to have been euthanised.
He searched the web for the Keyboard Pro model.
Retailers repeated the same five facts.
Wireless.
Rechargeable.
Comfortable.
Fast.
Easy.
Darren lowered the phone.
This wasn't simplification.
Simplification would have been reducing twenty specifications to ten.
This was the abolition of specification.
He left without buying anything.
At Supa Saver he bought unbranded EGGS, CHICKEN, RICE, and COFFEE. He wanted to know what completely generic products tasted like.
At home he ate standing at the kitchen counter.
Then he opened Excel.
He did not consider this an eccentric thing to do. Quite the reverse. If a pattern appeared to exist, the rational response was to stop experiencing it impressionistically and begin recording observations. Memory was noisy. Mood contaminated recall. Confirmation bias was real. Darren knew all this. He was not going to become one of those people who noticed three red cars and concluded that red cars were following him.
He created six columns.
OBJECT
REMEMBERED COMPLEXITY
CURRENT COMPLEXITY
CONFIDENCE
POSSIBLE EXPLANATION
VERIFICATION
Supa Saver coffee.
Supa Saver eggs.
Supa Saver chicken.
Supa Saver rice.
Ledgerly.
Self-help books.
Electronics retail taxonomy.
Keyboard specifications.
Monitor specifications.
He changed monitor to screen, stared at what he'd done, swore, and changed it back.
Possible explanations came easily.
Cost reduction.
Minimalist branding.
Consumer preference.
Accessibility.
Reduced decision fatigue.
Corporate imitation.
AI-generated product copy.
Market convergence.
His own selective attention.
His own memory.
That last one mattered.
Darren sat back.
He needed controls.
Things whose complexity he knew independently of recent impressions. Things he had encountered before this had begun, preferably things resistant to fashion, product management, marketing departments and consultants explaining that consumers became frightened when presented with nouns containing more than two syllables.
For several minutes he looked at the spreadsheet.
Then he remembered the bookshop.
Hamlet.
He had specifically checked it.
Not vaguely remembered it. Checked it.
Act Three. Scene One.
To be, or not to be, that is the question.
The rest had been there too: the movement of the thought, the qualifications, the language refusing to collapse into its own summary. He remembered the relief of it.
Darren added another row.
HAMLET
Under POSSIBLE EXPLANATION, he typed:
CONTROL
He saved the spreadsheet.
Tomorrow, Hamlet.

